Fiscal r-star

From Wikitia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Fiscal r-star
Also known asFiscal r*
FieldPublic finance, macroeconomics
SubjectGovernment debt sustainability
Related conceptNatural rate of interest (r*)
Main applicationFiscal policy and public debt analysis

Fiscal r-star (also written fiscal r*) is an economic concept that identifies the real interest rate at which a government's debt level is stable — neither rising nor falling as a share of GDP. It is the fiscal counterpart to the monetary policy concept of the natural rate of interest (r*), and provides a benchmark for assessing whether prevailing interest rates are putting upward pressure on public debt.

Background

The natural rate of interest, or r*, describes the real interest rate consistent with an economy running at full employment with stable inflation. First articulated by Knut Wicksell in the late 19th century, it was given an empirical foundation for modern central banking by Laubach and Williams (2003).[1]

Fiscal r-star applies the same logic to government finances. Rather than asking what interest rate keeps the economy in balance, it asks what interest rate keeps public debt stable. When actual interest rates rise above fiscal r*, debt tends to increase; when they fall below it, governments gain fiscal breathing room. The concept was introduced by Bolhuis, Koosakul, and Shenai (2024) in an IMF Working Paper.[2]

The Fiscal-Monetary Gap

A key related concept is the fiscal-monetary gap — the difference between the conventional monetary r* and fiscal r*:[3]

<math>\text{Fiscal-Monetary Gap} = r^m_* - r^f_*</math>

A positive gap means the interest rate consistent with monetary policy objectives is higher than the rate consistent with fiscal stability, implying that debt dynamics are deteriorating even when monetary policy is at its neutral setting. A negative gap means interest rates are providing a passive fiscal dividend.

When fiscal-monetary tensions are elevated, the authors argue that one of four outcomes must follow: rising public debt, fiscal consolidation, above-target inflation, or financial repression.[4] Drawing on 140 years of data from 16 advanced economies, Bolhuis et al. find that larger fiscal-monetary gaps are historically associated with all four outcomes, as well as with elevated risks of debt, currency, and financial crises.[5] Their estimates placed fiscal-monetary tensions at historic highs as of the mid-2020s — levels not seen since World War II.[6]

Applications and Policy Use

IMF Article IV Surveillance

Fiscal r-star has been adopted in IMF country surveillance. The 2024 Article IV Staff Report for the Czech Republic (IMF Country Report No. 2025/035) applies the concept in its fiscal sustainability analysis. The 2025 Colombia Staff Report (IMF Country Report No. 25/280) invokes fiscal r-star explicitly to define the primary balance required to stabilize Colombia's debt.

Reception in Policy and Academic Circles

The concept has been presented and discussed at a range of international policy institutions. Bolhuis, Koosakul, and Shenai presented the paper at the joint PIER–Asian Development Bank conference on monetary and fiscal policies in emerging markets (Bangkok, May 2024), where James Yetman of the Bank for International Settlements served as discussant.[7] The paper was subsequently presented at a research seminar at De Nederlandsche Bank (July 2025)[8] and featured in the Reserve Bank of Australia's annual conference proceedings (2025).[9]

BNP Paribas Economic Research cited fiscal r-star in its Q4 2024 Eco Perspectives editorial on fiscal consolidation in advanced economies, noting that the fiscal-monetary gap for a sample of 16 advanced countries had reached its highest level since the 1950s.[10] The concept was discussed in a Mercatus Center Macro Musings podcast episode (January 2025), in which Bolhuis explained the framework and its policy implications to a broad economics audience.[11] The Carlyle Group referenced fiscal r-star in a 2025 investment research publication examining the long-run outlook for fiscal and monetary policy interactions.[12]

Criticisms and Limitations

The concept faces several challenges. Fiscal r* cannot be directly observed and depends on estimates of potential growth and the sustainable primary balance, both of which are uncertain.[13] The primary balance is also somewhat endogenous — it can itself be affected by the level of interest rates — introducing circularity into the framework. As a long-run concept, fiscal r* is less useful for near-term policy guidance, and by focusing on aggregate debt dynamics it sets aside important practical factors such as debt maturity, investor composition, and rollover risk.

See Also

  • Natural rate of interest
  • Debt sustainability analysis
  • Primary balance
  • r minus g
  • Fiscal dominance
  • Financial repression

References

  1. ↑ Laubach, Thomas; Williams, John C. (2003). "Measuring the Natural Rate of Interest". Review of Economics and Statistics. 85 (4): 1063–1070.
  2. ↑ Bolhuis, Marijn A.; Koosakul, Jakree; Shenai, Neil (August 9, 2024). "Fiscal R-Star: Fiscal-Monetary Tensions and Implications for Policy". IMF Working Papers. 2024 (174). doi:10.5089/9798400282126.001.
  3. ↑ Bolhuis, Marijn A.; Koosakul, Jakree; Shenai, Neil (August 9, 2024). "Fiscal R-Star: Fiscal-Monetary Tensions and Implications for Policy". IMF Working Papers. 2024 (174). doi:10.5089/9798400282126.001.
  4. ↑ Bolhuis, Marijn A.; Koosakul, Jakree; Shenai, Neil (2024). "Mind the Gap: Gauging Fiscal-Monetary Tensions through Fiscal R-Star". VoxEU/CEPR.
  5. ↑ Bolhuis, Marijn A.; Koosakul, Jakree; Shenai, Neil (2024). "Fiscal R-Star: Fiscal-Monetary Tensions and Implications for Policy". SUERF Policy Brief.
  6. ↑ Bolhuis, Marijn A.; Koosakul, Jakree; Shenai, Neil (2024). "R Star Star Wars Episode II: Fiscal Policy Strikes Back". Financial Times.
  7. ↑ Bolhuis, Marijn A.; Koosakul, Jakree; Shenai, Neil (May 20, 2024). "Fiscal R-Star: Fiscal-Monetary Tensions and Implications for Policy". Monetary and Fiscal Policies in Emerging Markets amid Heightened Uncertainty. Discussant: James Yetman, Bank for International Settlements. Bangkok: Puey Ungphakorn Institute for Economic Research (PIER) and Asian Development Bank.
  8. ↑ Bolhuis, Marijn A. (July 10, 2025). "Fiscal R-Star: Fiscal-Monetary Tensions and Implications for Policy". De Nederlandsche Bank Research Seminars.
  9. ↑ Bolhuis, Marijn A.; Koosakul, Jakree; Shenai, Neil (2025). "Fiscal R-Star: Fiscal-Monetary Tensions and Implications for Policy — General Discussion" (PDF). Reserve Bank of Australia Annual Conference 2025. Reserve Bank of Australia.
  10. ↑ Baudchon, Hélène (October 9, 2024). "Editorial: The time has come for fiscal policy to adjust". BNP Paribas Economic Research (Eco Perspectives, Q4 2024).
  11. ↑ Beckworth, David; Bolhuis, Marijn A. (January 6, 2025). "Marijn Bolhuis on Fiscal R-star and its Implications for Macroeconomic Policy" (Podcast). Macro Musings. Mercatus Center at George Mason University.
  12. ↑ Thomas, Jason (September 2025). "Through the Looking Glass" (PDF). The Carlyle Group.
  13. ↑ Bolhuis, Marijn A.; Koosakul, Jakree; Shenai, Neil (August 9, 2024). "Fiscal R-Star: Fiscal-Monetary Tensions and Implications for Policy". IMF Working Papers. 2024 (174). doi:10.5089/9798400282126.001.

External links

Add External links

This article "Fiscal r-star" is from Wikipedia. The list of its authors can be seen in its historical. Articles taken from Draft Namespace on Wikipedia could be accessed on Wikipedia's Draft Namespace.